Choosing a bathtub is about more than finding a style you love.
The right bathtub should fit your bathroom layout, provide the comfort you’re looking for and make sense for how you actually use the space.
Two popular options are freestanding bathtubs and alcove bathtubs. Both offer advantages, but they’re designed for different situations.
Let’s look at what you should consider before choosing.
What Is a Freestanding Bathtub?
A freestanding bathtub is designed to stand independently rather than being enclosed by walls or a built-in surround.
These tubs are often chosen as a design feature, creating a focal point in the bathroom.
They come in a variety of shapes, sizes and finishes, from modern oval designs to more traditional styles.
Advantages of Freestanding Tubs
- Distinctive, high-end appearance.
- Available in a wide range of shapes and sizes.
- Can create a beautiful focal point.
- Offer flexibility in placement, depending on plumbing and room layout.
Things to Consider
Freestanding tubs require sufficient space around them.
One detail homeowners sometimes overlook is cleaning.
A tub placed close to a wall with a narrow gap behind it can be difficult to clean. Consider how much room you’ll have to reach around the tub before finalizing its location.
You’ll also need to consider the location of the tub filler, water supply and drain.
What Is an Alcove Bathtub?
An alcove bathtub is designed to fit into a recessed space, typically with three surrounding walls.
These tubs are commonly used in bathrooms where the bathtub also serves as the shower.
Advantages of Alcove Tubs
- Efficient use of available space.
- Practical for combined shower-and-bath layouts.
- Surrounding walls can provide opportunities for shelving and storage.
- Can create a more contained and straightforward cleaning area.
Things to Consider
Alcove tubs are generally more dependent on the existing bathroom layout and dimensions.
You’ll need to coordinate the tub with the surrounding wall system, waterproofing, shower fixtures and any glass enclosure or shower curtain.
Which Is Easier to Maintain?
This depends largely on the installation.
A freestanding tub with generous clearance around it can be easy to clean.
However, a tub positioned tightly against a wall may create awkward spaces that are difficult to reach.
An alcove tub can offer a more contained area, although the surrounding walls and corners still need appropriate cleaning and maintenance.
Consider the entire installation rather than the bathtub alone.
Don’t Choose Based on Length Alone
One of the biggest mistakes homeowners make is selecting a bathtub based only on its overall dimensions.
Comfort depends on the interior shape, too.
Before buying, consider:
- Interior soaking depth.
- Backrest angle.
- Interior length and width.
- Overall tub height.
- Ease of getting in and out.
- How the tub supports your body.
If possible, experience the shape in person.
Think About Your Tub Filler
Your bathtub filler needs to work with the tub you’ve selected.
Make sure the spout reaches the tub properly, the controls are accessible and the fixture doesn’t interfere with getting in or out.
Confirm the installation requirements and plumbing configuration before finalizing the location.
Consider a Handheld Attachment
A handheld shower attachment can be a useful addition to a bathtub.
It’s convenient for rinsing the tub, washing hair and bathing children.
Consider hose length, mounting location and how easily the handheld can be reached.
So, Which One Should You Choose?
A freestanding bathtub may be the right choice if you have the room and want the tub to be a design feature.
An alcove bathtub may be a better option if you’re working with a smaller bathroom or want a practical combination of shower and bath.
Neither is automatically better. The best choice is the one that suits your space and lifestyle.
The Bottom Line
A bathtub should be comfortable, practical and suited to your bathroom layout.
At Vanity Mart, we offer a variety of bathtub styles, faucets and bathroom products to help you create a space that works for you.
Visit our Waterloo showroom to explore your options and find the right bathtub for your renovation.